Saturday, July 17, 2010

Keynes and Consumption

All of a sudden, John Maynard Keynes has returned to the A-list. Exiled at the beginning of the Reagan administration, he is once again in vogue as the policies of Reagan and his successors have ended in an economic meltdown.

Keynes made his name during the Great Depression when he knocked Says law off its pedestal. Says law stated that supply and demand would always balance out in the long run. 1929 put the lie to that.

Instead, Keynes put forth a theory of aggregate demand in which he argued that demand evolves from the interaction of consumption, investment and government spending. In short, he believed that if consumption drops because of an economic downturn, then it was necessary to increase government spending, which would put money in the consumer’s pocket, which, in turn, would be used to buy goods, and this would stimulate the economy. (Of course, this implied that government spending be reduced in good times, something out leaders ignored during the Cold War.)

The only problem I have with Keynes theory is that it was developed when mass consumption was in its adolescence.

It is difficult to date exactly when the age of mass consumption began since several factors contributed to it. There was the sudden flooding of the consumer market with large quantities of mass produced goods that were affordable. Some argue that mass consumption really took off in the 1890s with the growth of corporate bureaucracies and the increased pay for white collar workers.

If we accept 1890 as an arbitrary start date, then Keynes formulated his theory when mass consumption was a little over forty years old. At this time, there was still room for growth in the consumer market. Many homes were without indoor plumbing or electricity. Coal or wood still heated houses and cooked the food. Clothes were washed by hand; fields were plowed by a team of mules; hot water had to be heated on the stove.

Now we fast forward to today when consumption is seventy percent of our GDP, and one could argue that much of this consumption has been superfluous since most of our basic needs were met in the go-go days of the fifties and sixties. In addition to that, this superfluous consumption has been floated on a sea of consumer debt.

How do you stimulate spending in a saturated consumer market? Whatever money is funneled into the consumer’s pocket will most likely go to pay down consumer debt. We have been floating on a consumer bubble, and it has popped. It is unlikely it will be re-inflated.

Like Icarus, our economy flew too close to the sun and has come crashing back to earth. There are no more wings to be had.


Seinbeetre said...

Fantastic post.

Consumerism and its inherent need for never ending growth are the biggest dangers human civilisation faces.

They will both come to an end sooner or later, whether we manage it by choice or it is done by force of reality.

I expect the latter.

Anonymous said...

Man, u have been firing these short shots that are loaded with wonderful cocktail of intellectual gun powder since a long time, keep up the good work, hardly get to read such thought provoking yet decent articles interesting take on Keynes.

monirujjaman khan said...

First Search Engine Marketing Company in Bangladesh. Providing Global Data Entry Jobs and Training. Also a worldwide ads publisher company in Bangladesh.
A search feature is also available to easily find your photos. The tag navigation help you to discover pictures without knowing the content of the gallery. Indeed, the most used tags are highlighted below the search.

Really very nice i have read these tips.

Global Data Entry Jobs
Global Data Entry Training
Welcome to the Bangladeshi Exporters
E-Z Rent-A-Car
Refresh Online Center

Anonymous said...

[url=]Phen375 375[/url] are tablets that supporter reduce confederation weight. One of these tabs has to be enchanted with ring false, round 20 minutes ahead of a repast, twice a day.

Anonymous said...

[url=]cash advance loans[/url]
This is the best way to get all your health products online like green coffee, african mango, phen375 and others. Visit now


Anonymous said...

what is garcinia cambogia extract[/url] is the richest adipose burning force out nearby in hawk for the nonce a days. Lose upto 10 kg in 1 month. garcinia cambogia select

Anonymous said...

Hello to every body, it's my first pay a quick visit of this website; this website consists of amazing and really excellent information designed for readers.

Here is my website :: please click the next document

Thai Lottery said...

This is a great post on Keynes and Consumption . It's really very informative and helpful post. Thanks for sharing

Sayed said...

It's really excellent information designed for readers. Thanks

dvdrip xvid free said...

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

>>>>>>Fast & Furious 6 (2013) DVDRip Xvid Full Movie Free Download<<<<<<

Minecraft gratuit said...

amagin, wow, really very good post it.Thank you for share.good bye.

dremland said...

want to be a proper freelancer? want to earn money from internet? please see out freelancing course to build your freelancing career. thanks

freelancing in bangladesh

buy google cirlce followers said...

eminent post with effective and useful information.its really nice post include a lot of resource.keep posting this kinds of article.thanks for share with us.good google cirlce followers

liquid handling system said...

This post contain a lot of information about recent wheel of events.i hope this article will be helpful for the reader’s.thank you very much for sharing with us.liquid handling system

get vine likes said...

Oh i am really shokking, this post is very nice. I really enjoy it. Thank you for sharing with us. Thanks again very much.get vine likes

liquid handling system said...

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I'm quite certain I will learn many new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next! Thank you for share.good bye.liquid handling system

buy facebook photo likes said...

A real informative blog like this is an exceptionally cool helping resource for a needy information seeker like me! Thanks a lot for share with us. Good bye.

buy instagram likes said...

This is really great site and it's gives more good information.thank you for share.I like this site.good bye.

buy google plus shares said...

this is very good site, i really enjoy it, thank you.good google plus shares

Coduri Postale Cluj Napoca said...

In a word very good blog. I just like it!
Coduri Postale Cluj Napoca

buy vine followers said...

Hi, its a really great blog post of i enjoyed lot.thanks again for share with us.good vine followers

palash said...

I think this article has been good for me, you can Share it thanks. bdtrainer

buy facebook fans said...

Yes blog commenting is still working if you do it properly. Means if you are doing it in quality manners and of same niche, then it will definitely work. Very nice post. Keep sharing like facebook fans

suit said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Bruna marquizine said...

Here is awesome place to view , travel and for visiting . Every one can get world's beautiful and historical place in the world can download more beautiful HD wallpaper from here.

wallpapers, background, desktop backgrounds, images, image, pictures, picture, hd, nature, technology, photography said...

Free collection of high quality high resolution wallpapers for computers, phones and mobile devices.

Travel the World said...

Information of beautiful places to visit around the world.Take a moment and discover the Most Beautiful Places of the World.

isbillah ksu said...


adam said...

[5/25/2014 4:52:06 PM] Biparna Bairagi: I can provide you 500 unique visitors per day
[5/25/2014 4:52:26 PM] frank mezza: how??
[5/25/2014 4:52:37 PM] Biparna Bairagi: if you want more I can give you 1000+ per day

adam said...

Good Morning all,
are you curious if your product content,software or E-book is being stolen??
Please take advantage of our free evaluation at
have a great day
regards, Emploodle

Buy Fast Fans said...

You want Buy Fast Fans? Click our Social Media Website.

Buy Fast Fans said...

You want Buy Fast Fans? Click our Social Media Website.